It’s the Ranch It Up Radio Show! Join Jeff “Tigger” Erhardt, Rebecca Wanner AKA BEC and their crew as they hear how using genomic testing can aid the selection of retaining replacement heifers. Plus, the latest news from cow country, upcoming sales, market recaps and lots more wrapped in this new episode of the Ranch It Up Radio Show. Be sure to subscribe on your favorite podcasting app or on the Ranch It Up Radio Show YouTube Channel.
Selecting Replacement Heifers: Building a More Productive and Profitable Cow Herd
Selecting replacement heifers is one of the most important decisions beef producers make each year. The females retained today will have a lasting impact on the future of the cow herd, influencing everything from genetic improvement and reproductive efficiency to development costs and long-term profitability.
But choosing replacements involves much more than keeping the biggest heifers, selecting the best-looking females or retaining a certain percentage of the calf crop. The real objective is to identify heifers with the genetic potential, reproductive capability and functional traits needed to become productive, profitable cows.
And successful replacement selection starts long before breeding season.
It’s important to remember that a heifer developed for breeding is not automatically a replacement. She’s a replacement candidate. Some candidates may be eliminated during development, others may fail to become pregnant, and some may not offer enough long-term value to justify keeping, even if they conceive.
The best replacement decisions come from evaluating heifers throughout the development process and using that information to identify females that fit the goals of your operation.
Start With a Clear Picture of Your Ideal Cow
Before evaluating individual heifers, producers need to determine what kind of cow they want in their herd. That means identifying the traits that have the greatest economic value to the operation.
Consider questions such as:
- What mature cow size best fits your available feed resources?
- How important are fertility, milk production, growth and longevity?
- Are you retaining females to produce future replacements?
- Are you primarily using terminal sires and marketing the resulting calves?
- What traits will make your cow herd more efficient and profitable?
These questions help establish a breeding objective and provide direction when evaluating genetic merit.
Expected Progeny Differences (EPDs), commercial genomic testing and economic selection indexes can all help identify females that align with those goals.
Genomic testing can be especially useful because it provides additional insight into an animal’s genetic potential. However, the value comes from using those results to make better selection decisions.
If producers plan to retain the same heifers regardless of their genomic results, testing is unlikely to make a meaningful difference in genetic progress. Instead, consider how many heifers need to be tested, when results will be available and how that information will influence final selection decisions.
Replacement Heifer Selection Is a Process, Not a One-Time Decision
An updated University of Missouri Extension publication, Selection of Replacement Heifers for Commercial Beef Cattle Operations, identifies three important stages for evaluating replacement candidates:
- Post-weaning
- Pre-breeding
- Pregnancy determination
Each stage provides an opportunity to evaluate candidates, eliminate females that don’t meet expectations and avoid investing additional development costs in heifers that may not fit the operation.
1. Post-Weaning Evaluation
At weaning, the goal isn’t necessarily to identify the biggest or most attractive heifers. Instead, producers should begin screening candidates for major concerns involving structural soundness, health and disposition.
Birth date and genetic merit also deserve attention. Heifers born earlier in the calving season generally have a better opportunity to reach puberty before breeding begins and conceive early in their first breeding season.
That early conception can have a lasting impact on reproductive success and lifetime productivity.
Genomic testing can also be incorporated into this first evaluation. Identifying heifers that don’t meet the operation’s genetic objectives early may help producers avoid unnecessary development expenses and determine which females are better suited for alternative marketing opportunities.
2. Pre-Breeding Evaluation
The next evaluation typically takes place four to six weeks before the start of breeding season.
At this point, producers should determine whether heifers have reached appropriate development and target weights. Reproductive tract scoring and pelvic measurements can also provide valuable information about reproductive maturity and readiness for breeding.
These evaluations help identify females that are progressing appropriately, candidates that may need additional management and heifers that should be removed from the replacement group.
The goal is to enter breeding season with a group of females that have the best opportunity to conceive and become productive members of the cow herd.
3. Pregnancy Determination
Pregnancy determination is one of the most important steps because this is where producers can make their final replacement decisions.
Not every heifer will become pregnant, and pregnancy alone shouldn’t automatically guarantee a place in the herd.
Producers should consider several factors when making final selections, including:
- Date of conception
- Genetic merit and breeding objectives
- Dam reproductive history and performance
- Structural soundness and overall phenotype
- Potential for long-term productivity
Combining this information helps identify females that offer the greatest opportunity for success in the cow herd.
Reproductive Performance Should Be a Top Priority
One of the most valuable traits to consider when selecting replacement females is reproductive efficiency, particularly how early a heifer conceives during her first breeding season.
Heifers that conceive early are more likely to calve early, remain productive longer and wean more total pounds of calf over their lifetimes.
This is another reason establishing and maintaining a defined breeding season is so important. It provides producers with a way to identify females that consistently breed early and meet the reproductive expectations of the operation.
Genetic potential is important, but a replacement heifer must also prove she can get the job done.
Dam performance is another valuable piece of the selection process. Did her mother breed early? Did she consistently wean a desirable calf? Did she maintain body condition and remain productive in the herd?
These records provide additional insight when comparing heifers with similar genetic merit and reproductive performance.
Visual appraisal also remains an important part of replacement selection. Structural soundness, feet and leg quality, udder characteristics, disposition and adaptability all influence a female’s ability to remain productive for years.
The key is to evaluate phenotype alongside genetic and reproductive information rather than allowing appearance alone to determine which females make the cut.
Develop a Replacement Strategy That Fits Your Operation
There isn’t one replacement heifer development and selection program that works for every beef operation.
The number of heifers developed, timing of genomic testing, target weights and selection criteria should all reflect available resources, marketing opportunities, breeding objectives and the overall economics of the operation.
What matters most is having a plan before selection decisions begin.
Know how many replacements you need. Identify the traits that matter most to your operation. Establish when heifers will be evaluated and determine what criteria females must meet to move forward.
Taking a more systematic approach can help producers make better genetic decisions, control development expenses and build a more productive cow herd.
Additional Resources for Selecting Replacement Heifers
University of Missouri Extension recently updated publication G2028, Selection of Replacement Heifers for Commercial Beef Cattle Operations, providing producers with additional guidance on the replacement selection process.
The publication covers the different stages of heifer evaluation, the use of genetic and reproductive information, genomic testing considerations and practical approaches to heifer development.
Whether you’re evaluating this year’s heifer crop or planning for next year’s replacements, it’s a valuable resource to have in your toolbox.
Remember, the replacement heifers you select today will help determine the productivity, efficiency and profitability of your cow herd for years to come. Choosing the right females isn’t just about building next year’s herd. It’s about building the future of your operation.
Bull & Heifer Sale Dates & Deadlines
November 14: JYJ Red Angus Production Sale, Columbia, Alabama
November 23: CK Cattle, Highmore, South Dakota
December 9: Gill Red Angus, Timber Lake, South Dakota
December 22: Mar Mac Farms Dispersal Sale, Brandon, Manitoba
Private Treaty: Storey Hereford Ranch, Bozeman, Montana
January 22: Ellingson Simmentals, Dahlen, North Dakota
January 25: Schriefer Red Angus, Golden Valley, North Dakota
January 27: Vollmer Angus Ranch, Wing, North Dakota
February 4: Stroh Hereford Ranch, KIlldeer, North Dakota
February 5: 6 Mile Angus, Flasher, North Dakota
Featured Experts in the Cattle Industry
Jamie Courter, Ph.D. – University of Missouri
https://extension.missouri.edu/programs/beef-extension
Follow on Facebook: @SteakGenomics
Shaye Wanner – Host of Casual Cattle Conversation
https://www.casualcattleconversations.com/
Follow on Facebook: @cattleconvos
Contact Us with Questions or Concerns
Have questions or feedback? Feel free to reach out via:
- Call/Text: 707-RANCH20 or 707-726-2420
- Email: RanchItUpShow@gmail.com
- Follow us: Facebook/Instagram: @RanchItUpShow
- YouTube: Subscribe to Ranch It Up Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/RanchItUp
Catch all episodes of the Ranch It Up Podcast available on all major podcasting platforms.
Discover the Heart of Rural America with Tigger & BEC
Ranching, farming, and the Western lifestyle are at the heart of everything we do. Tigger & BEC bring you exclusive insights from the world of working ranches, cattle farming, and sustainable beef production.
Learn more about Jeff ‘Tigger’ Erhardt & Rebecca Wanner (BEC) and their mission to promote the Western way of life at Tigger and BEC.
Industry References, Partners and Resources
For additional information on industry trends, products, and services, check out these trusted resources:
American Gelbvieh Association: https://gelbvieh.org/
EquineMarket.Com: https://www.equinemarket.com/
Imogene Ingredients: https://www.imogeneingredients.com/
Jorgensen Land & Cattle: https://jorgensenfarms.com
LivestockMarket.Com: https://www.livestockmarket.com/
RanchChannel.Com: https://ranchchannel.com/
RFD-TV: https://www.rfdtv.com/
Rural Radio Network: https://www.ruralradio147.com/
Sire Buyer: https://www.sirebuyer.com/
Superior Livestock: https://superiorlivestock.com/
Westway Feed Products: https://westwayfeed.com/
Wrangler: https://www.wrangler.com/
Related Episodes
Repro Health With Nutrition, Cattle News, Market Reports & More
Hear how Purnia Mills’ new product CX-8 helps with reproductive health in cattle, latest beef news, market reports.
Cattle News, Market Reports, Ranch Jobs & More
Hear the latest cattle industry news, market reports and elite ranch jobs available.
Feeding High Nitrate Hay, Cattle News, & Ranch Jobs
Hear how dilution is the solution when feeding hay high in nitrates, cattle news and the latest ranch job openings.
Partnering, Sponsoring or Advertising
Hire, Sponsor, Advertise
Want to expand your Marketing?
Want Tigger & BEC for Your Event?
Contact Us TODAY!









































